The Ultimate Cheese Toastie Recipe

The ultimate cheese toastie recipe

There’s no better antidote to cold winter weather than a hot cheese toastie, so we asked our cheesemonger and friend Rhuaridh of Buchanan’s Cheese, to share his ultimate cheese toastie recipe.

Ingredients:

  • 2 slices of sourdough – we used our Waste Bread
  • 100g Caerphilly cheese, crumbled
  • 100g Ham Hock – we used Waitrose’s Pulled Ham Hock
  • 1 leek, finely chopped into rings
  • Salted butter
  • Black pepper

    Method:

    1. Add a knob of butter to a frying pan, then add the leek and sweat it down until soft.
    2. Butter the bread on both sides, then start to fill the toastie, leek first, then a layer of ham hock, finish with the Caerphilly, holding back a small handful of cheese. Season with pepper and close the sandwich.
    3. Heat another knob of butter in the frying pan at a medium heat. Sprinkle in a little more cheese to go underneath the bread.
    4. Carefully place the toastie in the pan, then place a stack of plates on top to press it down. After about three minutes, remove the plates and check the sandwich. Flip the toastie once the underside is crisp and golden brown, sprinkling a little more cheese into the pan to go underneath.
    5. After another two to three minutes, make sure the toastie is golden on both sides.
    6. Serve it with a side salad, or eat it straight from the pan if, like us, you can’t wait.
    Back to journal
    • Feeding a Crowd?

      Whatever your plans, our sharing boxes are perfect for a gathering. Simply order 48 hours ahead on our website for delivery to your door or pick up from your local bakery.

      Order now 
    • Same Day Click & Collect

      Skip the queue by ordering your favourites through our app. We’ll make sure your order is wrapped and ready to collect from your local bakery at a time that suits you.

      Order now 
    • Delivered to your door

      Breakfast, lunch or afternoon tea, enjoy freshly baked goods, drinks and other treats delivered straight to your door with Deliveroo.

      Order now